Who owns businesses in California? A lawmaker wants the public to know.

By Yosi Yahoudai
Founder and Managing Partner

TRÂN NGUYỄN Associated Press

SACRAMENTO — A California lawmaker wants to require business owners and landlords to disclose their identities under legislation aimed at cracking down on opaque ownership structures that have enabled some companies to skirt state laws without facing consequences.

Limited liability companies and similar corporations in the United States are often formed to protect a business owner’s personal assets. In California, the world’s fifth largest economy, such businesses are already required to register with the Secretary of State and share information including the name of the business, its address and the names of its executives or representatives.

But Democratic state Sen. Maria Elana Durazo said that that’s not enough. She also wants the public to know who actually owns the company. Her bill would require these companies to list anyone who owns at least 25% of the company’s assets on its registration with the state. It would apply to all LLCs and similar corporations regardless of the size.

People are also reading…

Durazo said the lack of that crucial information has allowed people to set up business structures in which one company is owned in the name of another, all to shield their identities from the public, government officials and even law enforcement agencies. In many cases, local and state officials must spend significant time and resources to track down the owners before they can charge or sue the business for violating state laws, if they can find them at all.

“Some owners can abuse LLC to shield not only their assets but also their identities,” Durazo said at a hearing Wednesday. “This is a good governance bill.”

With support from labor, housing and environmental groups, her bill passed a key legislative committee Wednesday. There was no debate. It needs a second committee vote before reaching the Senate floor.

A similar proposal last year did not survive the Legislature’s suspense file, a mysterious process by which lawmakers decide — with no explanation — whether bills should move forward or not.

The legislation faces fierce opposition from a number of business groups including those that represent landlords. They argue that LLCs must already share lots of information with the government and note that they will be required to disclose ownership to a branch of the U.S. Treasury Department by 2025.

They also point to costs. Last year, the secretary of state estimated the new disclosure requirement would cost $9 million to implement and an additional $3.4 million annually in subsequent years to employ 28 support workers.

“It really doesn’t make any sense to us,” said Debra Carlton, an executive of the California Apartment Association. “Why add these costs onto the state,” she asked, “when we’re already having financial challenges?”

The practice of operating business anonymously is prevalent in many California industries, proponents of the bill said. In Oakland, after city officials condemned a dilapidated building rented out to low-income immigrant families, the city attorney’s office spent more than a year investigating and combing through hundreds of city code enforcement records to find the owners of the building, said Suzie Dershowitz, who worked on the case at the time. The city eventually found and successfully sued the landlords, who owned more than 130 properties in the city through a network of LLCs and corporations. The investigation would have taken half a day of work if Durazo’s bill was law at the time, she added.

“As a government agency, I had access to a lot of information,” said Dershowitz, who now works for Public Advocates, an advocacy group sponsoring the bill. “But the lack of transparency in corporate ownership really hampered our investigation.”

Some employers also rely on the practice to dodge labor violations and cheat workers out of their pay, labor attorney Ruth Silver-Taube said. She pointed to a case in San Jose where a hotel worker was fired from his job for filing a wage theft claim with the state. The state couldn’t track down the business owners and had to name 14 different companies, some of which were defunct, in its lawsuit before the owners agreed to settle, she said. The agreement came nine years after the worker filed the initial complaint.

“Justice delayed is justice denied,” Silver-Taube said.

By hiding behind an anonymous LLC, Silicon Valley billionaires were successful in shielding their identities in a secretive $800 million land-buying spree in rural Solano County, despite years of local scrutiny.

Others managed to dodge legal ramifications and responsibilities altogether through the practice, said Haley Ehlers of climate watchdog organization Climate First: Replacing Oil & Gas. The group has spent years advocating for the removal of orphan and idle wells left behind by defunct oil operations. Orphan wells are often sold to private, anonymous shell companies designed to go bankrupt to help owners of oil businesses evade legal responsibility to clean up the site, leaving taxpayers to shoulder the cost, she said.

“If we had more owner transparency, bad actors wouldn’t be able to hide behind a new shell company name,” Ehlers said.

The federal reporting requirement was passed by Congress in 2021. The legislation requires businesses to report owners to an agency called the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, which aims to cut down on shell corporations and money laundering. But currently, only law enforcement and government officials — not the public — have access to the information.

A federal court ruled that the law is unconstitutional and exempted more than 65,000 members of a small business association in Alabama. The Justice Department is now appealing the ruling.

New York last December also passed a proposal mirroring the federal legislation to require the disclosure of owners, but the information is only available to some government and law enforcement agencies.

New legislation is aimed at giving fans more choice when buying concert or sports tickets.

PHOTOS: Walk a Mile in Her Shoes Steps toward justice

A volunteer gets a pair of red high-heel shoes on Sunday, April 14 as people gather at Veterans Memorial Park in Napa for the Walk a Mile in Her Shoes event for sexual assault awareness and prevention.

Nick Otto, Register Walk a Mile 2

Tracy Lamb, executive director of the NEWS women’s services agency, spoke to participants at the start of the Walk a Mile in Her Shoes event on Sunday, April 14.

Nick Otto, Register Walk a Mile 3

Participants are seen walking past China Point overlook in downtown Napa as they participate in Walk a Mile in Her Shoes an event that brings awareness to sexual assault on Sunday, April 14.

Nick Otto, Register Walk a Mile 4

Kyle Eddleman, a Lieutenant with the Napa County Sheriff’s office wears red high heel shoes as he and a team of Napa County first responders prepare to participate in Walk a Mile in Her Shoes, an event that brings awareness to sexual assault on Sunday, April 14.

Nick Otto, Register Walk a Mile 5

Hundreds hold signs as they cross the second street bridge in downtown Napa while participating in Walk a Mile in Her Shoes an event that brings awareness to sexual assault on Sunday, April 14.

Nick Otto, Register Walk a Mile 6

A participant in red high heeled shoes walks along the side walk in downtown Napa as they take part in Walk a Mile in Her Shoes an event that brings awareness to sexual assault on Sunday, April 14.

Nick Otto, Register Walk a Mile 7

Participants holding signs speaking out against sexual assault chat before taking part in Walk a Mile in Her Shoes an event that brings awareness to sexual assault on Sunday, April 14.

Nick Otto, Register Walk a Mile 8

Calistoga Police Chief Mitch Celaya holds a sign and wears red high heel shoes before taking part in Walk a Mile in Her Shoes an event that brings awareness to sexual assault on Sunday, April 14.

Nick Otto, Register Walk a Mile 9

Hundreds carry signs as they walk along Second Street in downtown Napa to take part in Walk a Mile in Her Shoes, the annual Napa event that brings awareness to sexual assault, on Sunday, April 14.

Nick Otto, Register Walk a Mile 10